Do better reviews let hotels charge more? What the data says
Short answer: yes, according to the best-known study on the question. Cornell's Center for Hospitality Research found that a hotel scoring 1 point higher on a 5-point OTA review scale could raise its price by 11.2% and keep the same booking probability. It's a 2012 average for city hotels, so treat it as a direction to test, not a guarantee.
By Nadav Baram · Published
The key numbers
From Anderson (2012), The Impact of Social Media on Lodging Performance, Cornell Center for Hospitality Research.
The reputation analysis used more than 31,000 monthly observations over about 2.5 years, from midscale, upscale and luxury hotels in 11 cities in North America and Europe.
The study, in plain words
In 2012, Chris Anderson of Cornell's Center for Hospitality Research combined data from three research partners (Travelocity, STR and ReviewPro), plus comScore and TripAdvisor, to answer a question owners still ask: does reputation show up in revenue?
1. Travelocity bookings
Using real transactions, he modelled whether a guest booked, given price and review score. A hotel 1 point higher on the 5-point scale could charge 11.2% more and still be chosen as often.
2. Reputation vs. performance
He matched ReviewPro's Global Review Index, a score combining reviews across sites, with STR's hotel performance data for London, Milan, Rome, Madrid, Berlin, Prague, Chicago, Los Angeles, New York, San Francisco and Miami. A 1% better reputation went with up to 0.89% higher ADR, up to 0.54% higher occupancy and up to 1.42% higher RevPAR.
Why guests pay more for a better score
A hotel room is bought before it's experienced. The guest can't test the bed, hear the street noise or meet the receptionist. Reviews are the closest thing to a test drive. A higher score lowers the risk of a bad stay, and people will pay to lower risk.
The report also notes that OTA reviews, both their quality and their number, go with higher conversion. That's the same idea from another side: at the same price, more people say yes.
What the study does not tell you
- It's an average, not a promise. Your hotel won't automatically earn 11.2% more if your score rises.
- It shows a link, not proof of cause. Better hotels may get both better reviews and higher prices because of something else, like location or product.
- The data is from 2012 and from city hotels in North America and Europe. Small independents, hostels and LatAm leisure markets weren't studied directly.
- Scales differ. The 11.2% figure uses a 5-point scale. Booking.com uses 10 points, so don't convert the number directly.
- Who supplied the data. ReviewPro, which sells reputation software, was a Cornell research partner and provided the reputation index. Independent peer-reviewed research points the same way: Yacouel and Fleischer (2012, Journal of Travel Research) found that reviews published through online travel agencies create a price premium for hotels with good reputations.
The hidden catch: your reputation lives on someone else's platform
Yacouel and Fleischer's finding has an uncomfortable side. The price premium is built by the OTA publishing your reviews. Your most valuable pricing asset sits on Booking.com's and Expedia's servers, which is one more reason OTAs hold so much power over independent hotels.
The practical answer isn't to fight reviews on OTAs. It's to make sure the same proof follows the guest to your direct channels: your website, your booking engine and your Google profile. More in our guide to OTA vs direct bookings.
What it could mean for a 30-room hotel
Here's an illustration, not a forecast. Take a 30-room hotel at a $100 ADR and 70% occupancy, so 21 rooms sold a night. If the 2012 average applied to it, an 11.2% higher rate at the same occupancy would mean:
The point is the order of magnitude. Compare it with what you'd spend fixing the two complaints your guests mention most. Try your own numbers in the hotel ROI calculator.
Try this: a 4–8 week reputation-to-rate experiment
- Baseline. Write down your review score on each OTA and on Google, your ADR and occupancy for the last 90 days, and the scores and rates of 3–5 direct competitors.
- Fix the repeat complaints. Read your last 50 reviews. Complaints usually cluster: noise, Wi-Fi, check-in, breakfast. Fix the top two.
- Ask at the peak moment. Request reviews when the guest is happiest (after a great tour, at breakfast on the last day), not only by automated email after checkout. See perceived value and reviews.
- Test the rate, not a discount. When your score passes a competitor's, raise one or two room types by 3–5% for four weeks. Watch conversion in your extranet, pickup and occupancy against the same period.
- Decide with data. Keep the increase if occupancy holds. Roll it back if it doesn't. Then repeat. This is what dynamic pricing looks like in practice.
Frequently asked questions
Do online reviews affect hotel prices?
Yes. A Cornell study found that a 1-point higher review score on a 5-point OTA scale let hotels charge 11.2% more with the same booking probability, and peer-reviewed research also finds a price premium for well-reviewed hotels.
How much is one review point worth to a hotel?
In Cornell's 2012 analysis of Travelocity bookings, one point on a 5-point scale was worth an 11.2% price increase at the same market share. Your result will depend on your market, segment and competitors.
Does a better online reputation increase RevPAR?
In the same study, a 1% higher online reputation score went with up to 1.42% higher RevPAR, from up to 0.89% higher ADR and up to 0.54% higher occupancy.
Should I lower my price or improve my reviews first?
Look at reviews first. If your score is below your competitors', a discount may just cover a reputation gap. Fix repeat complaints, then test rates.
Does this apply to Booking.com's 10-point scale?
The study used a 5-point scale, so the 11.2% doesn't convert directly. The direction (higher score, more pricing power) is what to apply, and then test with your own data.
Is the Cornell study still relevant?
It's from 2012, but the reason behind it, that guests use reviews to reduce the risk of a bad stay, hasn't changed. Use it as a hypothesis and confirm it with your own numbers.
Sources
- Anderson, C. K. (2012). The Impact of Social Media on Lodging Performance. Cornell Hospitality Report, Center for Hospitality Research. Cornell eCommons · Virginia Tech summary
- Cornell Hospitality Research press release, 16 November 2012, via Hospitality Net
- Yacouel, N., & Fleischer, A. (2012). The role of cybermediaries in reputation building and price premiums in the online hotel market. Journal of Travel Research, 51(2), 219–226. doi:10.1177/0047287511400611
Nadav Baram is the founder of KPIbara. He was General Manager of Selina Playa and Selina River in Panama, where Booking.com scores rose from 7.4 and 7.2 to 9.0, and founded Hostal Bambú in Colombia (9.6 on Booking.com, Tripadvisor top 1% of hostels worldwide 2020–2022). M.S. in Neuropsychology & Research, Universitat de Barcelona.
What are your reviews worth in rate?
Book a free 30-minute revenue review. Your top 3 priorities in writing within 48 hours.
Book a free review